Skip to content

Schreiber's European cyclocross title dispute could end up in court, just like the 1988 World Championships

Cyclocross
marie-schreiber

Follow IDL Pro Cycling on Google

Stay up to date with the best cycling news by making us a preferred source on Google.

Follow us on Google
Marie Schreiber crossed the line first in Zeddam, but Lucinda Brand is the one with the European Champions jersey. The fight over that title may not end in cycling's own system. The case could be settled by the Court of Arbitration for Sport or in another legal forum. It compares the case to one of the sport's most notorious sprints.
ADVERTISEMENT
Read more below the photo.
marie-schreiber
Schreiber reported harsh treatment by the European Championship judges

Luxembourg wants the finishing order restored

ADVERTISEMENT
The Luxembourg federation (FSCL) has formally challenged the jury's decision with the European Cycling Union (UEC). "That is why the FSCL is calling for the race standings to be determined based on the order in which the riders crossed the finish line," its statement read.
The UEC organises the championships but does not handle disciplinary matters on race day. That job falls to a UCI jury of commissaires.
Filing a complaint does not give a rider or federation the right to an appeal, as Velora notes. Schreiber and her federation could in theory take the case to CAS, where the UCI's disciplinary decisions are regularly challenged.
ADVERTISEMENT
Schreiber's coach Sanne Cant has already raised that possibility. Asked by Sporza about legal action, she said: "That may be the case. Because we are not going to let this go."
Schreiber herself has said she does not expect the commissioners to back down. She described the process in details after the race: "I tried to tell my side of the story there and explain what had happened, but they didn’t even let me finish speaking.”
Read more below the photo.

Ronse 1988: Bauer, Criquielion and Fondriest

ADVERTISEMENT
Stickybottle have pointed to the 1988 World Championship road race in Ronse, Belgium, as an example to folloe.
Three riders sprinted for the rainbow jersey: Canada's Steve Bauer, Belgium's Claude Criquielion and Italy's Maurizio Fondriest.
Criquielion tried to pass Bauer on the inside, against the barriers, and crashed. Fondriest came around to win, and a furious Criquielion walked his bike over the line.
The judges disqualified Bauer, but the Belgian wanted more than that. Criquielion sued Bauer for assault and claimed $1.5 million in damages.
The criminal court in Oudenaarde cleared Bauer, and the appeal court in Ghent cleared him again. Accounts of how long the case lasted differ. Canadian Cycling Magazine says it took three and a half years, while other sources say it ran for more than five years.
ADVERTISEMENT
Read more below the video.

Bauer, Criquielion and Fondriest at Ronse 1988.

Why the European Cyclocross Championships is a different case

Criquielion went to court for money and was not trying to change the result. In Zeddam, the result itself is what is being disputed, and no third rider slipped through to take the win as Fondriest did in 1988. According to Stickybottle, that makes this result easier to reverse.
The strongest argument may come from the rider who was given the title. Brand told the commissioners that Schreiber had done nothing wrong. This would amount to very strong evidence in Schreiber's favour if the case ever reached a courtroom.
For now, the official result has not changed, and Brand is still European champion.

Latest Cycling News

Popular Cycling News

Latest Comments

Loading